Boudinot's Change: Boudinot, Emerson, and Ross on Cherokee RemovalBy Bethany Schneider in ELH; Spring2008, Vol. 75 Issue 1, p151-177.
With his writings for the Cherokee Phoenix, Elias Boudinot established himself as a foremost Cherokee intellectual and patriot. However, his admiration for the United States as a model for culture and government caused him to be seen as a tragic figure caught between conflicting cultural values. His signature on the Treaty of New Echota, which set the scene for the “Trail of Tears”, and his execution by his countrymen for treason against the Cherokee Nation has earned him the reputation of a traitor. As the editor of the Cherokee Phoenix he stood publicly against the removal of native Indians to lands across Mississippi, but in 1831 and 1832 he changed his mind. The writer discusses Boudinot's change of mind before exploring the interventions made by philosopher Ralph Waldo Emerson and Cherokee Principal Chief Ross into the debate on Indian removals.